top of page
  • OSS Writing

Self-Publishing vs. Traditional Publishing: Weighing the Pros and Cons

Self-publishing vs. traditional publishing

When it comes to publishing their books, authors are faced with a crucial decision: whether to pursue traditional publishing or go the self-publishing route. Each path offers its own set of advantages and challenges, and the choice ultimately depends on the author's goals, preferences, and priorities. Today, we'll explore the pros and cons of self-publishing vs traditional publishing, providing insights to help authors make an informed decision about their publishing journey.


Self-publishing vs. traditional publishing

Self-publishing empowers authors to take full control of the publishing process, from manuscript preparation to distribution and marketing. Here are some key pros and cons of self-publishing:


  • Creative Control - One of the biggest advantages of self-publishing is the ability to retain complete creative control over your work. From cover design and formatting to pricing and marketing, self-published authors have the freedom to make decisions that align with their artistic vision.

  • Speed to Market - Self-publishing allows authors to bring their books to market quickly, bypassing the lengthy timelines associated with traditional publishing. With digital distribution platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) and IngramSpark, authors can publish their books in a matter of days or weeks, reaching readers worldwide.

  • Higher Royalties - Self-published authors typically earn higher royalties per book sale compared to traditionally published authors. By cutting out the middleman (i.e., literary agents and publishing houses), self-published authors can retain a larger percentage of their book's profits.

  • Flexibility - Self-publishing offers flexibility in terms of content, genre, and niche markets. Authors are not bound by the preferences of traditional publishers and can explore unconventional topics or cater to niche audiences that may be underserved by traditional publishing.


  • Limited Distribution - While digital distribution platforms offer access to a global audience, self-published authors may struggle to secure placement in brick-and-mortar bookstores and libraries. Traditional publishers often have established distribution networks and relationships with retailers, providing greater visibility for their books.

  • Quality Control - If they don’t seek the support of professional editors, designers, and marketers, self-published authors may encounter challenges in ensuring the quality and professionalism of their books. Poorly edited manuscripts, amateurish cover designs, and ineffective marketing strategies can undermine the credibility of self-published works.

  • Marketing and Promotion - Self-publishing requires authors to take on the role of marketer and promoter, which can be daunting for those without experience in book marketing. Building an author platform, engaging with readers, and implementing effective marketing strategies are essential for gaining visibility and driving book sales.

Self-publishing vs. traditional publishing

Traditional Publishing

Traditional publishing involves partnering with a publishing house or literary agent to bring a book to market. While traditional publishing offers the allure of prestige and professional support, it also comes with its own set of pros and cons:


  • Professional Support - Traditional publishers provide authors with access to a team of professionals, including editors, designers, marketers, and publicists, who collaborate to refine and promote the author's work. This support can enhance the quality and marketability of the book, increasing its chances of success.

  • Distribution Channels - Traditional publishers have established distribution networks and relationships with retailers, making it easier for books to secure placement in bookstores, libraries, and online retailers. This broader distribution reach can lead to greater exposure and higher sales potential for traditionally published books.

  • Prestige and Validation - Landing a publishing deal with a reputable publishing house can confer a sense of legitimacy and validation upon an author's work. Traditional publishing is often associated with prestige, awards, and recognition within the literary community, which can boost an author's reputation and credibility.


  • Lack of Control - Traditional publishing entails relinquishing a degree of creative control to the publishing house, which may have final say over aspects such as cover design, title selection, and marketing strategies. Authors may find themselves compromising on certain artistic decisions to align with the publisher's vision and market expectations.

  • Longer Timelines - The traditional publishing process can be lengthy and time-consuming, involving multiple rounds of submissions, revisions, and editorial reviews. From the time a manuscript is acquired to its release date, it may take months or even years for a traditionally published book to reach readers, leading to frustration and impatience for authors eager to see their work in print.

  • Royalties and Advances - While traditional publishing offers the potential for advance payments and royalty advances, authors typically receive lower royalty rates per book sale compared to self-publishing. Additionally, advances are not guaranteed, and authors may need to share a percentage of their earnings with literary agents and publishers.

Self-Publishing vs. Traditional Publishing - Which is Right for You?

The decision between self-publishing and traditional publishing is a deeply personal one that depends on a variety of factors, including the author's goals, preferences, and resources. Both paths offer unique opportunities and challenges, and there is no one-size-fits-all approach to publishing success. Whether you choose to pursue self-publishing or traditional publishing, the most important thing is to stay informed, be prepared to put in the hard work, and never lose sight of your passion for writing. Whatever path you choose, One Small Step Writing is here to support you on your publishing journey with expert guidance and personalized solutions tailored to your needs.

5 views0 comments


bottom of page