top of page
  • OSS Writing

Editing vs Revising: Strategies for Polishing Your Fantasy Manuscript

Editing vs Revising

Writing a fantasy manuscript is a labor of love, and the journey from the first draft to the final masterpiece involves a crucial step—polishing. As a fantasy writer, you're not just crafting a story; you're building an entire world. In this article, we delve into the intricacies of two essential processes: editing and revising. Understanding the distinctions between them and employing effective strategies can make the difference between a good fantasy novel and an extraordinary one.

Editing: The Art of Refinement

Editing vs Revising

Before diving into the nuances of editing a fantasy manuscript, it's crucial to differentiate between editing and revising. Editing is the initial step in the refinement process, focusing on the overall structure, clarity, and coherence of your narrative. It involves addressing macro-level issues to ensure that the story flows seamlessly.

Best Practices for Editing a Fantasy Novel

Big-Picture Assessment

Begin with an overarching evaluation of your fantasy manuscript. Examine the plot, character arcs, and world-building elements. Ensure that the storyline is engaging and the fantasy world is vividly realized.

Consistency in World-Building

Fantasy novels often involve intricate world-building. During the editing phase, pay close attention to details like magic systems, rules, and geography. Ensure consistency throughout the narrative to immerse readers in your fantastical realm.

Character Development

Characters are the heart of any story. Assess the depth of your characters, their motivations, and how they contribute to the overall narrative. Editing is the time to refine character arcs and relationships.

Pacing and Tension

Fantasy novels can be expansive, but pacing is critical. Evaluate the rhythm of your story, ensuring that tension is maintained, and crucial events are appropriately spaced. Eliminate unnecessary scenes that may hinder the flow.

Language and Style

While editing, focus on the language and style of your writing. Ensure that your prose aligns with the tone of your fantasy world. Eliminate redundancies, refine dialogue, and sharpen descriptions to captivate your readers.

Editing vs Revising

Revising: Polishing the Details

Revising a Fantasy Manuscript

After the initial edit, the focus shifts to revising—a process that involves fine-tuning the details. Revision is about perfecting the manuscript at a micro level, addressing sentence structure, grammar, and ensuring that every word serves a purpose in enhancing the narrative.

Effective Strategies for Revising Your Fantasy Novel

Sentence-Level Refinement

Scrutinize each sentence for clarity and impact. Ensure that your prose is polished, eliminating any awkward phrasing or ambiguity. Pay attention to the rhythm of your sentences to create a captivating reading experience.

Grammar and Punctuation

A well-revised fantasy manuscript is free from grammatical errors and punctuation mishaps. Use grammar-check tools and meticulously proofread to catch any overlooked mistakes. Consistency in punctuation contributes to the professional quality of your work.

Show, Don't Tell

Revising is the perfect time to refine the balance between showing and telling. Instead of explicitly stating emotions or details, find ways to illustrate them through actions, dialogue, and sensory descriptions. This adds depth to your narrative.

Dialogue Enhancement

Dialogue is a powerful tool in fantasy storytelling. During the revision process, ensure that each character's voice is distinct and authentic. Trim unnecessary dialogue tags and replace them with meaningful actions to convey emotions.

Thematic Coherence

Revisit your manuscript with a focus on thematic elements. Ensure that your fantasy novel conveys a cohesive message or theme. Fine-tune symbols, motifs, and recurring elements to enhance the depth and resonance of your story.

In the intricate dance of creating a fantasy novel, editing and revising are partners. Editing lays the foundation, addressing major elements like plot and character development, while revising adds the finishing touches, refining every sentence and nuance. Both processes are vital, and the key to success lies in understanding when to switch from one to the other.

Editing vs Revising

Seeking Expert Advice: The Crucial Step in Crafting a Masterpiece

While the editing and revising process is an intimate journey between you and your manuscript, the wisdom of a professional editor is an invaluable compass guiding you towards literary excellence. A seasoned editor brings a fresh perspective, keen eyes, and a wealth of experience to the table. Their ability to identify blind spots, provide constructive feedback, and suggest enhancements can elevate your fantasy novel to new heights. Engaging a professional editor is not just about polishing your prose; it's a commitment to delivering a refined, professional product to your readers. 

Understanding the types of editing and revisign offered is important as you seek professional help. Developmental editing shapes the overarching structure and elements of a fantasy manuscript, copy editing refines the prose and style at the sentence level, and proofreading ensures a flawless, error-free presentation in the final stages of manuscript development. While each plays a crucial role, the sequence in which they are employed is equally important. Begin with developmental editing to shape the grand narrative, then move to copy editing to refine the language and style. Finally, employ proofreading as the finishing touch to catch any lingering errors. This sequential approach ensures that each layer of editing builds upon the last, resulting in a fantasy manuscript that is not only compelling but also impeccably crafted. 

Fantasy storytelling is a dynamic genre where creativity knows no bounds. By aligning with the right type of editing and revising at each stage, you can produce a masterpiece that transports readers to realms beyond their imagination. The professional editing step not only ensures a polished story but also builds credibility with your audience. Readers appreciate the meticulous attention to detail and coherence that an editor's insights can bring, establishing trust in the quality of your work. In the realm of fantasy storytelling, where world-building intricacies and narrative nuances are paramount, the collaboration with a professional editor becomes an indispensable bridge between your creative vision and a captivating, well-crafted tale.

As you embark on the editing vs revising journey with your fantasy manuscript, remember that each stage serves a unique purpose. Embrace the iterative nature of writing, and don't be afraid to revisit both macro and micro elements and leverage professional knowledge until your fantasy world gleams with literary brilliance. In the end, the synergy between editing and revising will transform your initial draft into a captivating fantasy masterpiece.

2 views0 comments


bottom of page